NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Cottage Cheese vs. Milk

facial device

The NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil is a popular choice among makeup enthusiasts for its creamy texture and versatile application. In this blog post, we will be comparing two of the most loved shades from this range – Cottage Cheese and Milk. Join us as we explore the differences between these shades and help you decide which one suits your eye makeup needs the best.

Related:

China beauty products manufacturer

NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Cottage Cheese

Cottage Cheese is a unique shade that adds a touch of shimmer and brightness to your eye looks. Here’s what you need to know about this shade:

  1. Pigmentation and Finish: Cottage Cheese has a soft white base with subtle silver shimmer. The pigmentation is buildable, allowing you to achieve a sheer wash of color or a more intense look depending on your preference. The finish is frosty and illuminating, making it perfect for creating a bright-eyed effect.
  2. Suitable Eye Makeup Looks and Occasions: Cottage Cheese works exceptionally well as an inner corner highlight, giving your eyes a pop of light and creating a more awake appearance. It can also be used as a brow bone highlight or blended onto the center of the eyelid for a spotlight effect. This shade is ideal for both daytime and nighttime looks, adding a touch of elegance and glamour.
  3. Pros and Cons of Using Cottage Cheese:
  4. Pros:
    1. Versatile shade for various eye makeup looks
    1. Shimmery finish adds a luminous touch
    1. Creamy texture for smooth application
  5. Cons:
    1. Requires building up for more intense pigmentation
    1. May not be suitable for those seeking a matte finish

NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Milk

Milk is a classic white shade that serves as an excellent base for creating vibrant and impactful eye makeup looks. Let’s dive into the details of this shade:

  1. Pigmentation and Finish: Milk offers a highly pigmented, opaque white color payoff. Its creamy formula glides on smoothly, ensuring effortless application. The finish is matte, providing a blank canvas for vibrant eyeshadow colors to stand out and pop.
  2. Suitable Eye Makeup Looks and Occasions: Milk is primarily used as an eyeshadow base to intensify the vibrancy of other eyeshadow shades. It helps colors appear more true to pan and enhances their longevity. Additionally, Milk can be used to create graphic eyeliner looks or as a highlight on the waterline to make the eyes appear larger and brighter.
  3. Pros and Cons of Using Milk:
  4. Pros:
    1. Intensely pigmented for vibrant eye looks
    1. Matte finish for a clean and precise application
    1. Enhances the longevity of eyeshadow
  5. Cons:
    1. May require extra blending to achieve a seamless finish
    1. Matte finish may not be suitable for those seeking a shimmery effect

Comparison between Cottage Cheese and Milk

Now that we have explored the individual characteristics of Cottage Cheese and Milk, let’s compare them side by side:

  1. Pigmentation and Intensity Comparison: While Cottage Cheese provides a sheerer and more buildable pigmentation, Milk delivers intense and opaque coverage from the start. If you prefer a subtle shimmer, Cottage Cheese is the way to go. However, if you want a bold and solid white base, Milk is the perfect choice.
  2. Differences in Finish and Texture: Cottage Cheese has a frosty, shimmery finish, adding a touch of luminosity to your eye looks. On the other hand, Milk offers a matte finish, providing a clean and precise canvas for vibrant eyeshadow colors to shine.
  3. Versatility and Range of Eye Makeup Looks: Cottage Cheese is versatile in creating bright-eyed effects, highlighting the inner corners and brow bones. It adds a touch of elegance and glamour to both daytime and nighttime looks. In contrast, Milk’s primary use lies in intensifying eyeshadow colors, making them appear more vibrant and true to pan. It serves as an excellent base for creating bold and impactful eye makeup looks.
  4. Longevity and Smudging Potential: Both Cottage Cheese and Milk have good longevity once set. However, due to its shimmery finish, Cottage Cheese may have a slightly higher tendency to transfer or smudge compared to the matte finish of Milk. To enhance the longevity of both shades, it is recommended to use an eyeshadow primer or set them with a matching eyeshadow color.
  5. Suitability for Different Skin Tones and Eye Colors: Cottage Cheese works well across various skin tones, as the subtle silver shimmer complements different undertones. It particularly enhances fair to medium skin tones. Milk, being a pure white shade, is suitable for all skin tones, especially for creating contrast and vibrancy on deeper skin tones. Additionally, both shades can complement a wide range of eye colors, from light to dark.

Final Verdict

In conclusion, both NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil shades, Cottage Cheese and Milk, have their own unique qualities and purposes:

  • Cottage Cheese adds a touch of shimmer and brightness, perfect for creating bright-eyed effects and subtle highlights.
  • Milk provides a solid white base with a matte finish, ideal for intensifying eyeshadow colors and creating bold eye makeup looks.

Ultimately, the choice between Cottage Cheese and Milk depends on your personal preferences and the specific eye makeup looks you want to achieve. Consider factors such as the desired level of shimmer, finish, and the intensity of the base color when making your decision.

We encourage you to try both shades and experiment with different eye looks to discover your favorite. The NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil range offers a wide array of versatile shades that can elevate your eye makeup game.

Additional Tips and Recommendations

To make the most of your NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil experience, here are some additional tips and recommendations:

  1. Application and Blending: Use a light hand when applying Cottage Cheese or Milk to avoid tugging on the delicate eyelid skin. For a seamless finish, gently blend the edges with a clean brush or your fingertip.
  2. Complementary Eyeshadow Colors: Experiment with different eyeshadow colors to create stunning combinations with Cottage Cheese or Milk as a base. Jewel tones, pastels, or even smoky hues can be beautifully enhanced by these shades.
  3. Alternative Uses for the Jumbo Eye Pencil: Apart from their primary purpose as eye makeup products, Cottage Cheese and Milk can also be used as highlighters on the face or as a base for lip colors to make them pop.

Conclusion

We compared NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil shades Cottage Cheese and Milk. We discussed their pigmentation, finishes, suitable eye makeup looks, pros and cons, and provided a comprehensive comparison. Ultimately, the choice between Cottage Cheese and Milk depends on your personal preferences and the specific eye looks you wish to create. Don’t be afraid to experiment and have fun with these versatile shades to elevate your eye makeup game.